Professional analysis. Credible evidence. Informed decisions.
The Caster standard
“A property value should be supported because the evidence supports it—not merely because someone calculated it.”
01Verify the propertyFacts before assumptions
02Test the marketComparable, relevant evidence
03Explain the answerClear, defensible reasoning
20Years in assessment
5×District Assessor of the Year
IIIIndiana Level III certified
25Years of Army leadership
Three service areas. One standard.
Start with the evidence.
Choose the service that fits your question: a property review, assessment consulting, or practical professional training.
01
Property owners
Assessment Review & Appeals
Determine whether the facts support the value before committing time and money to an appeal.
Property record and assessment review
Comparable-sales analysis
Residential, agricultural, and commercial appeals
PTABOA preparation and support
For accepted residential and qualifying agricultural appeals, the success fee is $50 for an informal or PTABOA outcome, or $100 total if the matter is successful at the IBTR. The fees are not cumulative, and no fee is owed without verified tax savings.
02
Government & industry
Assessment Consulting
Experienced project support for local governments, assessment offices, appraisal firms, and organizations.
Ratio studies and market analysis
Neighborhood and valuation review
Appeal and hearing preparation
Workflow, quality control, and AI policy
03
Professional development
Training & Education
Practical instruction built by someone who has managed the work, explained it, and defended it.
Artificial intelligence for assessors
Ratio studies and uniformity
Appeals and burden of proof
Leadership and taxpayer communication
How it works
A better appeal begins with better preparation.
Start with an inquiry. We discuss the scope and fees before you commit to an assignment.
01
Send the property
Email the address, parcel number if available, and your concern. Attach your assessment notice or property record card.
02
Review the record
Property characteristics, valuation components, and available documents are examined.
03
Test the evidence
Relevant sales, market influences, and valuation information are weighed.
04
Discuss the finding
You receive a plain-language explanation of what the evidence supports.
05
Build the case
When an appeal is justified, the evidence is organized for resolution or hearing.
Property assessment appeal fees
No tax savings. No professional fee.
Residential and qualifying agricultural appeals: $50 when a successful informal or PTABOA outcome produces verified tax savings, or $100 total if the matter is successful at the IBTR. The fees are not cumulative, and no fee is owed without verified tax savings. Commercial and industrial appeals remain 35% of documented first-year tax savings.
Residential & qualifying agricultural
Informal & PTABOA
$50 success fee
One $50 fee applies when an informal resolution or PTABOA decision produces verified first-year property-tax savings.
Residential & qualifying agricultural
Indiana Board of Tax Review
$100 total success fee
If the matter is successful at the IBTR, the total fee for the same parcel and assessment year is $100. Any $50 fee already paid is credited toward that total, so the fees are not cumulative.
Commercial & industrial
Accepted appeal engagement
35%
Thirty-five percent of documented first-year property-tax savings at the final appeal level included in the agreement.
What counts as success?
Verified first-year property-tax savings—not only a reduction in assessed value.
What is included?
Routine research, prescribed forms, preparation, and ordinary county-level representation.
What requires approval?
Third-party expenses require advance written approval. IBTR representation requires a separate signed addendum.
Written agreement before representation. Every client receives a written engagement agreement before representation begins. It identifies the scope of work, the applicable fee, and any separately approved costs.
Qualifying residential and agricultural matters are accepted after review. Complex income-producing, multi-parcel, exemption, personal-property, legal, or unusually complex matters may require a separate agreement. Final terms are governed by the signed engagement agreement.
For organizations
Experience available when you need it.
Not every challenge requires another full-time employee.
Caster Consulting can step into a defined project, review a difficult valuation issue, help prepare for appeals, strengthen office procedures, or provide an independent assessment perspective.
Ratio studiesMarket reviewComplex propertyAppealsOffice operationsResponsible AI
Preparation Integrity Accountability
Founder & principal consultant
George Caster
Twenty years of assessment experience, shaped by twenty-five years of military leadership.
George Caster’s career includes real property valuation, mass appraisal, market and comparable-sales analysis, ratio studies, residential and commercial appeals, PTABOA proceedings, taxpayer communication, and the administration of a county assessment office.
His United States Army service established the leadership principles that continue to guide the work: preparation, discipline, accountability, service, and completing the mission correctly.
Five consecutive District Assessor of the Year awardsIndiana Level III Assessor-AppraiserIndiana Certified Tax RepresentativeInternational Association of Assessing Officers memberNACo Professional Development Academy honors graduate in Leadership and Artificial Intelligence25-year United States Army veteran
Independent by design. Caster Consulting begins operations after George’s governmental service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by any county office or government agency.
Our Commitment to Every Property Owner
“Caster Consulting's responsibility is not simply to obtain a reduction in assessed value. It is to determine whether the assessment is fair, accurate, and supportable—and to advocate for a correction when the evidence justifies it.”
George Caster, Founder, Caster Consulting
Our vision
Fair and defensible property assessment.
To become Indiana's most trusted independent resource for fair, understandable, and defensible property assessment, where valuation decisions are guided by accurate information, credible market evidence, and accountable professional judgment.
Our mission
Turn that standard into practical service.
Caster Consulting provides independent, evidence-based property assessment analysis, appeal support, and professional consulting. We help property owners, businesses, and governmental organizations reach fair, understandable, and defensible valuation decisions through credible evidence, professional judgment, integrity, and experience.
Property assessment resource center
Understand the value before you challenge it.
Clear guidance for property owners preparing to make an informed decision.
01
Assessment vs. property tax
Why the assessor does not determine your final tax bill—and what else affects it.
02
What makes a good comparable?
Location matters, but so do age, condition, quality, size, land, and timing.
03
Should I appeal an increase?
The percentage of change gets attention. The resulting market value decides the case.
04
Preparing for PTABOA
A focused presentation is more persuasive than a stack of unrelated information.
Official Indiana forms
Always begin with the current prescribed form.
Appeal and representation forms can change. Use the official state catalogs at the time of filing rather than relying on an older saved copy.
Frequently asked questions
Know what to expect.
Assessment appeals are valuation matters. These answers cover the questions property owners ask most often.
Does an increase mean I should appeal?
No. An increase may justify a closer look, but the central issue is whether the new value is supported by credible evidence.
Can you guarantee a reduction?
No responsible valuation professional should guarantee a result before examining the property and evidence. Recommendations follow the analysis.
I found a nearby sale for less. Is that enough?
Not necessarily. A sale must be tested for location, property type, size, age, quality, condition, land, amenities, sale date, and market circumstances.
Do you handle commercial property?
Yes. Commercial work is reviewed individually and may require income, expense, vacancy, capitalization, cost, depreciation, and market information.
What does “We don’t win, you don’t pay” apply to?
It applies to accepted property-assessment appeal engagements under a written contingency agreement. Residential and qualifying agricultural matters have a $50 success fee for an informal or PTABOA outcome, or $100 total if successful at the Indiana Board of Tax Review. Any $50 fee already paid is credited toward the $100 total, so the fees are not cumulative. If the appeal produces no verified first-year property-tax savings, the professional fee is $0. Commercial and industrial matters use 35% of documented first-year savings.
How do you measure a successful appeal?
Success means actual, documented first-year property-tax savings attributable to the accepted appeal—not merely a lower assessed value. The same tax year, rates, deductions, credits, exemptions, and caps are used to isolate the appeal’s economic result.
Are you a law firm or government office?
No. Caster Consulting is an independent private assessment and valuation consulting practice. It does not provide legal, tax, or financial advice.
Evidence first. Appeals when justified.
You have the right to question your assessment.
Make sure you have the evidence to support the answer.